Skip to main content

"No child processes" error

A problem was reported by a customer. They were getting a failure and in the logs it reported

error → waitpid failed 'Reason: No child processes'
The “No child processes” error came from waitpid() after using  fork/spawn to launch a utility to load data into a data base.


Upon detailed investigation it appears it is possible that some other process that the user is running has changed the default handler for SIGCHLD - possibly the shell (e.g. bash!) used to launch our server processes. If the signal handler is set to SIG_IGN then when a process is started using fork()/exec() the return code from the process is NOT returned and waitpid() cannot retrieve the response code.

The most likely reason for "No child processes" error from waitpid() is that the signal handler for child processes (SIGCHLD) is not set to SIG_DFL. This should not be possible however it seems that on Linux a process run in the shell (or maybe a shell process) can set it to SIG_IGN or some other handler.
I reproduced the “No child processes” error by setting the signal handler for SIGCHLD to SIG_IGN using signal(SIGCHLD, SIG_IGN).

The fix is to always set the handler to SIG_DFL to ensure the correct behavior.
Using strace will show the signals getting set. As it was at a customer installation I added logging to report if the signal handler was not set to SIG_DFL (the function signal(SIGCHLD, SIG_DFL) will return the value of the original signal handler). Unfortunately I didn't get confirmation , the problem is no longer occurring after the fix was delivered!
References:
https://colinxy.github.io/computer-science/2017/01/27/bash-handles-signals.html
https://xaizek.github.io/2014-10-05/why-restoring-signal-handlers-is-important/

 (originally published in my other blog -> no child processes error on linux)

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Vising another office - What do you need when you arrive?

One of the challenges when traveling is being able to connect and charge all the different devices we take with us. These devices differ depending on the purpose of the trip (business or pleasure) but have the same challenges.When traveling for pleasure you may be staying with relatives, friends or at an AirBnB. What is available may be unknown. Many hotels cater for international travelers and have sockets that allow many different plugs to be used - The JW Marriott in Bangalore allows you to plug in any type of plug (all that I have seen!). One hotel in Sydney had USB charger ports available. The first challenge is being able to plug your charger in. When traveling for work I always carry two adapters that convert from the local plug standard to the plugs required for my devices and chargers. An alternative is to carry one adapter and a power board. The exception to the two adapters is when I am traveling to multiple countries which have different plugs! In those cases...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Art Of Debugging

My first taste of commercial software development came using Adabas / Natural - a data base with a 3GL programming language. There were no debuggers available but it had an interpreted development environment and you could write code and use print statements to debug your code. I was amazed when I was asked by another developer to help fix a bug in his code and observed that they did not use the same debugging technique. This developers debugging technique was to (apparently randomly) choose a line or two of code, change something, and rerun their application to see if the outcome changed. A couple of print statements quickly narrowed down the problem and had their program working. I found my productivity was many times better just because I had mastered that simple debugging technique. It took me minutes to fix a problem rather than days (or never!). One day I volunteered to port an imap implementation to OS/2. I thought that because it was written for Unix and on my OS/2 developmen...
Post a Comment
Read more